Wednesday, March 14, 2012

Let's Close The Book On This Town Meeting Petition

Ken O’Brien

The proponents of the petition to return Southbridge to a Town Meeting/Board of Selectmen form of government repeatedly cite the 1979 Appeals Court Decision in Marino v. Southbridge as the legal basis of their case.

In that case, the court stated:

JAMES J. MARINO & others vs. TOWN COUNCIL OF SOUTHBRIDGE.
7 Mass. App. Ct. 461
February 15, 1979 - April 25, 1979
Worcester County
Present: BROWN, GREANEY, & KASS, JJ. 

Pg. 464

Action by petition of the inhabitants of a town to the Legislature is apt for raising the comparatively discrete question of charter revocation, because it does not set in motion the elaborate process for action required by Sections 3 and 4(2) of the Home Rule Amendment and G. L. c. 43B, Sections 4 and 10, particularly the selection of a charter commission. The language of the Home Rule Amendment and c. 43B deals with charter adoption, amendment or revision. It does not mention revocation. The avenue of charter repeal by initiative-referendum-petition frustrates no legislative purpose articulated in c. 43B or in the Home Rule Amendment; it introduces no cacophonous strains, as the town council would have us think, into the harmony of general and local law; and it confirms the right of self-government by the inhabitants of a city or town. [Emphasis added]

I have repeatedly cited Chapter 43B, Section 10 of MGL as the fundamental legal problem with this proposal. This section of the court’s opinion states that as a specific impediment to such a proposal if it seeks to do other than repeal the existing Charter and return to the prior form of government.

Chapter 43B, Section 10 states:

Section 10. (a) Amendments to a city or town charter previously adopted or revised under this chapter may be proposed by the city council of a city or the town meeting of a town by a two thirds vote in the manner provided by this section; provided, that amendments of a city charter may be proposed only with the concurrence of the mayor in every city that has a mayor, and that only a charter commission elected under this chapter may propose any change in a charter relating in any way to the composition, mode of election or appointment, or terms of office of the legislative body, the mayor or city manager, or the board of selectmen or town manager. In this section, the word “mayor” shall mean an officer elected by the voters as the chief executive officer of a city or an officer lawfully acting as such, and the term “two thirds vote” shall mean, in cities, a vote, taken by yeas and nays, of two thirds of the members of a city council present and voting thereon, and shall mean, in towns, the vote of two thirds of the voters present and voting at a duly called meeting. [Emphasis added]

What more do you need to demonstrate that this petition is fatally flawed?

7 comments:

  1. The real issue is that 43B, Sect. 10 applies equally to the Charter amendment proposed by the town council to change the vote required to remove the town manager.

    But, this ill-conceived distraction has undermined any concerted effort to oppose that proposal.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The way I'm reading this is you keep bringing up this 43B Sect. 10 but nobody else,meaning the courts is interpreting it the way you do. It just aint resonating with anybody that has a legal say. Sorry I know you care but I think all these things are allowed the way they are written. The case you listed above mentions the argument you are making,it does not reinforce it. Good luck on your campaign to undo these things but looks to me like everything is AOk on the legal side for the courts in MA.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ken, let them say what they will. Their track record isn't that good, and in the process of being know-it-all's, they're pushing people that would normally support them further and further away. It's what they're getting really good at. In the end, they can say what they want...we spent what, a year, on the Charter Review Committee? We don't know it all, but we certainly know more than most. Good luck, Aaron, but the courts are not interpreting it that way. Your comment is not factually based, but emotionally based. A lawyer's opinion is just that: an opinion. It doesn't mean that they're right, either. That's up to the courts, my friend.

      Delete
    2. It is a step backward plain and simple. I've participated in Open Town Meeting, and council form of government. Open town meeting is a joke. People come out to the meeting for one issue and leave. some times they break the quorum.

      Town Hall and school employees and their families stack the meeting to pass their pay raises and leave. This is why this form of government was abandoned in Southbridge to begin with, they couldn't conduct the town business properly.

      I believe Jim Sotille asked for someone with a JD to weigh in yet accepts this Aaron's word without refuting the fact that he's not a lawyer. Like Ken said, where's your proof?

      If you paid good money for a legal opinion then you need to attach it with the petition and make it public. After all, your petition is a public document because you're proposing a public policy change. You have asked a previous poster to pony up money to see the legal opinion? I don't think that is right. We the people have a right to see all the documentation you have justifying this activity. If you don't produce it, you're being deceitful.

      Delete
    3. Aaron:

      The court in the Marino case interpreted it precisely that way.

      Read the decision again.

      Delete
  3. Rob raises a point I hadn't considered and am compelled to agree with.

    This is an initiative petition seeking public support in the form of signatures to revise a public charter. The 2002 Charter Commission, a duly elected body with specific legal authority to act undertook a year long process in which they conducted research, studies, publicly posted meetings, and hearings.

    They published the details of the new Charter in the local papers with a final report and extensive minutes well in advance of the public vote so the people knew and understood what they were voting on. The Charter Review Committee appointed in 2009 did the same. The same cannot be said for this initiative.

    As stated in the final report of the charter review committee, we conducted twice monthly meetings, three public hearings and sought public input.

    During theses sessions I do not recall at any point during the process anyone advocating or suggesting we revert to this form of government.

    Key in this process was that it was all done through public discourse and debate, transparently, and the use of expert opinion both legal and administrative.
    These documents were all filed with the Town Clerk's office and on the Town's Website and are available for public inspection.

    Adopting, revising or amending a public charter is a public process. Any group or governmental entity seeking to do so should make all documentation available for inspection by the public. If United Southbridge is in possession of expert legal opinions stating that this procedure is in order and proper with the proper rational and citation of case law, it should be made available for inspection to anyone who requests it. I would assert it should be part of the information packet being used to solicit signatures for the petition.

    The legal opinion may have been obtained using private money but because it is for a public purpose it should be provided to alleviate any concerns potential signers have as to whether this is a proper method for charter revision.

    On a closing note, I was opposed to the manner in which, in my view, the current Council majority hijacked and tainted the Charter Review process. I am equally opposed to the manner in which this group has conducted their process and seeks to do the same. In my view this process was less transparent than that of the Council.

    Meetings were not announced publicly but kept private amongst a small group. There are no meeting minutes to review. Meetings were held in private facilities not public buildings. These facts in and of themselves undermine the process from the outset.

    I feel it is important for me to remain true to my oath of office, my constituents, and my conviction that the current charter which was overwhelmingly voted by the people of Southbridge is a fundamentally sound document.

    The current governmental problems are not systemic; they're related to human factors. We simply have people who interpret the charter the way it suits them rather than the way it was framed to suit the people. The Council majority is not providing the proper checks and balances, oversight, or holding the administration accountable to following the Charter. It is the Council and/or administration that need to change, philosophically, or physically, but not the form of government.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I want to emphasize I am not oppossed to the people behind this effort or to their right to try to effect change. I have always advocated for following a valid and reliable process. That is the cornerstone to good governance in my view.

    I am not trying to assert that the lack of openess was by design or intentional. I am simply stating it has occurred and there is a potential problem with it.

    For anyone to develop an informed opinion, they should be armed with information, that is the point of open and transparent government.

    Here is a link to an article from the Tewksbury Town Crier which is considering a move from the Open Town Meeting to Town Council Form of Government. In my judgment, this article clearly states the difference between the forms of government.

    http://homenewshere.com/tewksbury_town_crier/news/article_c5aa7d3c-4b16-11e1-b037-0019bb2963f4.html

    This is the type of dialog that should be occurring.

    Another good resource is this link to the Secretary of State's Website that talks about Open Town Meeting form of Government:

    http://www.sec.state.ma.us/cis/cistwn/twnidx.htm

    Again, I think there are problems with this and the stated conditions of government are not accurately reflected in the document that make it clear what is happening. There are specific rules for Adopting, revising and amending a Charter. There is a booklet put out on the subject through the Secretary of State's Office.

    Based on my knowledge of that I think Ken is correct based on the fact we have an existing Home Rule Charter that was done by the Home Rule amendment method. The first Charter was adopted in 1973.

    A second Charter was adopted in 2003 which repealed the first Charter. Based on these facts I don't think this petition is the correct way and I don't believe JAMES J. MARINO & others vs. TOWN COUNCIL OF SOUTHBRIDGE. 7 Mass. App. Ct. 461 February 15, 1979 - April 25, 1979 indicates it will accomplish what the petitioners are seeking.

    I say so because they've not articulated what charter they're revising or amending. They're not adpoting a new Charter so the only two methods is through revising or amendment. The Marino opinion in my view deals with voting to rescind the vote of people on adopting the first Charter thus reverting to the Selectman Open Meeting form of government.

    That opinion was rendered in 1979 - 1980 and based upon circumstances that no longer exist, they've changed. Based on this lack of clarity, I cannot support the petition as presently worded.

    ReplyDelete

All comments subject to moderation. All commenters must use their own name or a screen name. No comments labelled as "Anonymous" will be published. To use your name or a screen name select "Name/URL" from the drop down menu. Insert you name in the "Name" space and leave the "URL" space blank.